Great Southern Distillery: Old Rip Van Winkle

If you know Pappy Van Winkle, chances are you know of him as a rare and elusive beacon of bourbon, spoken of in hushed tones, reverence, an almost mythical epitome of what bourbon can and should be. If you don’t know Pappy Van Winkle, well… you’ll be better off once you make his acquaintance.

When thinking about great Southern distilleries, it’s hard to argue that there is one more distinguished or revered than Old Rip Van Winkle. The history of the Old Rip Van Winkle Distillery is deep – four generations of Van Winkles working in the heart of Kentucky bourbon country, turning out some of the most prized spirits the world over. Julian P. “Pappy” Van Winkle was born in Danville, Kentucky, and after college (in the late 1800’s) moved to Louisville to work for W.L. Weller. Pappy soon joined a friend in taking over W.L. Weller as well as the Stitzel Distillery, forming the Stitzel-Weller Distillery. They produced bourbon for brands including W.L. Weller, Old Fitzgerald, and Rebel Yell. When Pappy passed away in 1965 at 91 years of age, Julian, Jr., took over. After being forced to sell off the distillery’s brands, Julian, Jr., resurrected the pre-prohibition “Old Rip Van Winkle” label that you see today. Julian, III, took over in 1981 and still leads the charge for this venerable brand of bourbon. And Pappy? The Pappy Van Winkle moniker is reserved for the most precious bottlings in their line – the 15 year old, 20 year old, and 23 year old aged bourbons.

So, what is it that distinguishes Old Rip Van Winkle, and, more specifically, their Pappy Van Winkle bourbons? There is, of course, the family heritage. Julian, III, recognizes the importance of the place and the heritage of Kentucky bourbon, praising “the water, weather & expertise of the people who make bourbon here in Kentucky.” True, Pappy Van Winkle wouldn’t be the same if it were produced anywhere else. He understands that the heritage and the end product are inherently intertwined, saying, “We are very proud to be Southerners, and from Kentucky, which I think comes through in the whiskey we make.”

What else sets them apart? There is the dedication and patience of focusing on bourbons aged from 15 to 23 years. There is the rarity – limited releases just twice a year that seem to disappear from shelves as quickly as they arrive. And, then, there is the recipe, specifically the use of wheat, rather than rye, in addition to the corn and barley. The family holds that the wheat is the key to their bourbon’s slow but magnificent evolution as it ages through the years in deep charred heavy oak, and it’s hard to argue with the results. Julian, III, commented on the aging process: “As the bourbon gets older, it picks up more color and flavor from the charred new oak barrels. Each year in the barrel produces different flavor in the whiskey, picking up more oak as it ages. As it gets older, our wheated bourbon recipe becomes more smooth, with less of a bite. The 20 year Pappy is actually the smoothest of all. After 20 years, it has become almost like a cognac.” Indeed, just a whiff of the 23 year old Pappy is all it takes to recognize that something magical happens in those final years in the barrel, an evolution, a transformation that must be experienced firsthand to truly be appreciated. Did you notice the legend on the label next to the image of Rip Van Winkle, “asleep many years in the wood”? Just like the fabled Rip Van Winkle’s 20 years of sleep, the Pappy Van Winkle emerges from its time “in the wood” in a cloud of magic and mystery.

In addition to the lineup shown above – which includes the 23 year old Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve, the 20 year old Pappy, the 15 year old Pappy, and the two 10 year Old Rip Van Winkle Handmade Bourbons (90 proof and 107 proof) – there are two very-hard-to-find special reserves, the 12 year old Van Winkle Special Reserve and a 13 year old Van Winkle Family Reserve Rye. The awards and honors for Pappy Van Winkle are too numerous to count, but suffice it to say that each and every bottle is worth trying. If you ask us, the 15 year old Pappy is the bargain of the bunch (if you can find it), but if you have a chance to try the 20 year old and 23 year old, you will be privy to a rare and utterly unique experience in bourbon tasting. Hours can be spent over them, taking in the aroma, the history, the deep layers of concentrated Kentucky goodness.

18 Responses to Great Southern Distillery: Old Rip Van Winkle

  1. Dennis says:

    Brad,
    Excellent write up.
    Very informative piece. I think I need to find some 15.

    My only problem with Pappy is that I don’t drink it enough!
    Cheers.

  2. LTF says:

    Well done man. All of the Pappy talk in twitter reminded me to get caught up on your blog, and low and behold, I find a fantastic history of my favorite bourbon.

    My parents have been bugging me for a Christmas gift list from me for a week now. I just sent them an email and all it said was:

    “A bottle of Pappy Van Winkle, 20 yr. And socks.”

    Awesome post.

    Now I want bourbon.

  3. baker says:

    Great post. Been hearing so much buzz about Van Winkle but (sadly) have yet to try it. Know it’s tough to come by … what stores in Atlanta carry it on occasion?

    • Jonathan, your best bet to taste them is to belly up to the bar somewhere like Empire State South (where a few of those photos were taken actually) or H. Harper Station and compare a few different ones. It’s hard to find at retail frankly, once it’s in, it tends to sell out quickly. Give Tower, Toco Giant, and Mac’s a call. That said, more out of the way liquor stores might have a better chance of still having a bottle on the shelf since a lot of folks turn to Tower/Toco/Mac’s first! The fall release hit stores several weeks ago. Even the bars like H. Harper Station and Empire State South will likely run out of some of their bottles before the spring release gets here in roughly 5 months.

      • baker says:

        Outstanding. I’m a big fan of Empire and have been itching to get over to H.H.S.

        Thanks so much for the advice, and for the great piece. Keep it up.

  4. Pingback: Irish Whiskey Best in Blog: News and Tasting Notes on the Web | Whisky Party

  5. Scott says:

    Just got a bottle of 20yr and a bottle of 12yr SR. I CAN’T WAIT! I am almost nervous to open the bottles!

  6. Pingback: Ten Sinfully Southern Reasons to Consider the Atlanta Food & Wine Festival | Thirsty South

  7. Pingback: Happy (Pappy) Friday! | Real Estater

  8. Bill Leitch says:

    WHERE CAN I FIND IT ? I HAVE LOOKED EVERY WHERE AND NO ONE HAS IT ! CAN I ORDER DIRECT (VIA PHONE ?) I LIVE IN CA PS: I WAS ABLE TO BUY SOME IN LAS VEGAS NV A FEW MONTHS BACK BUT NOW THEY ARE COMPLETELY SOLD OUT AND THEY ARE NOT RECEIVING ANY (15-20 YEAR OLD) ! THEY KEEP TELLING ME THAT IT HAS BEEN ON ORDER FOR SEVERAL MONTHS (WHAT IS THE PROBLEM ?) I WOULD LIKE TO ORDER A COUPLE OF CASES

  9. Bill, good luck, locating some Pappy is hard work. The best bet is to establish a relationship with a local retailer that gets allocations (twice a year) and have them put your name on their waiting list ASAP. Of course, that probably means you won’t see anything until spring. That plus searching random stores (and asking, the Pappy is often kept in the back, not out on a shelf).

  10. Josh says:

    Great read! December 2011 has been an awesome month. I put my name on a waiting list back in June and was fortunate enough to receive a call to pick up my bottle! The CSR from Total Wine told me they had a bottle for me and asked if I was interested?!? I was down there ASAP! Just last night, I found a bottle of the Van Winkle 12 year at a store on the way home! I live 50 miles outside of Atlanta and suddenly my ITP friends remember how to get to my house. Keep up the great work!!!

  11. Thanks, Josh. Nice going on nabbing some good bottles, ever on the lookout.

  12. Pingback: Pappy Van Winkle Rye vs. High West Rendezvous Rye: Tasting NotesThirsty South

  13. Pingback: Pappy Van Winkle Old Fashioned Cocktail | Thirsty South

Comments welcome, y'all!